“The history of Quebec is a history of saviours, self-proclaimed or real. … The history of post-1960 Quebec politics is of political titans with huge successes and even more spectacular failures, of massive rises and even steeper collapses. … More bluntly, Quebecers have been begging for a saviour.”
In August, before the Quebec election started, I wrote that passage in the context of Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, another charismatic separatist again trying to bring Quebec to the brink of a referendum on a whim and a prayer of better days, deflecting from the fact that the idea makes no sense and will leave Quebec hopelessly divided and vulnerable just through the act of holding one. But it’s weirdly the story of this campaign for another reason - the rise of one new saviour and the crashing down of who we thought might have been Quebec’s Carney.
The fall of Christine Frechette is a reminder that this is what usually happens to party leaders coming in on a rescue job. Carney was the aberration, someone who through circumstance, and through his lack of connection to the government he was inheriting, was able to save the ship. Frechette wasn’t similarly disconnected from Legault, nor was the idea that she was ready for a crisis ever really tested. It was assumed, but taken for granted, in a way that Carney’s Bank of Canada and Bank of England time actually deserved.
The story of the election hasn’t been that, or PSPP, or the fact that Charles Milliard has been invisible. The story is Eric Duhaime, the Conservative leader and former radio host who has catapulted them above the CAQ and in contention for a shitload of seats. At the start of the campaign I used The Smiths as a motif, so it’s only fitting I use them again, because right now the story of the election is whether Quebec is willing to actually entrust the fate of their next National Assembly to the hands of Quebec’s latest Charming Man.
..
Duhaime and the Quebec Conservatives rose to the infamy they had at the last election as the home of disgruntled anti-lockdown/vax mandates people - a position that, given Legault’s dumbass curfew, was slightly more defensible than in other parts of Canada - but got absolutely destroyed on the altar of first past the post. The fact the Conservatives could get double digits and no seats is an abomination, given they only got 1.5% less of the vote than the Liberals and the Liberals got 21 seats. Duhaime in that election was a firebrand on an issue that had some juice basically everywhere but little concentration outside the capital. Now? He’s transformed, and has basically become the CAQ.
The basic premise of this election is that the PQ will beat the Liberals if it’s a straight fight, but the chance of a non-PQ majority comes from the presence of a third party that is right of centre, francophone focused, anti-referendum but certainly not the Anglo-focused Liberals, to win seats in the capital and in the 450 - Laval and to the north, the Eastern Townships, and the south shore. The CAQ under Legault was that party, putting up strong numbers in those areas even in 2012 and 2014, and the hope for the anti-referendum side was that they could claw back to 23% of the vote and stop the PQ across much of that area.
Obviously it would have been better if Milliard’s Liberals could have done it, but he has been lifeless and frankly pathetic this whole campaign. He has been unable to bring himself to the centre of the campaign, he’s been reduced to an afterthought, and nobody can make a compelling or even remotely coherent argument for why we need a Milliard government in specific, as opposed to just not wanting a PQ one. And that’s why we are where we are, with the Duhaime surge that could see us with a minority Parliament despite the CAQ’s uselessness.
The PQ absolutely could set (what I am 99% sure is) a record for lowest vote share to deliver a majority government in Canadian history on Monday. Anybody suggesting they definitely will or definitely won’t is either engaged in hackery or ignorant of just how many seats there are where the gaps between first and third are within 10%. Seat projections when 4 parties are unlikely to be within 7% of their previous vote share and at least two will be 12%+ away are impossible to do with precision, which is why I’m not doing them.
But I have a guess, and I would only say a guess, at how tomorrow plays out. The CAQ are going to be decimated, but I doubt they’ll be entirely wiped out - between incumbents who did a very good job of campaigning in their seats and the fact that I think most of the models’ methods accentuate the CAQ’s decline, I think they’ll win a handful of seats. The Ontario Liberals in 2018 did better than expected in Ottawa and somehow held one of their Thunder Bay seats - random shit can happen even as collapse is the overarching story.
The Liberals will probably do fine - not great, not good enough given the opportunity it had in front of it, but their seat count probably starts with a 3 and they will see it as a success because they’ve revived their vote share and Milliard will have retained official opposition. I will strenuously disagree this was a success but nobody will agree with me, and Milliard will likely fight another election, and I’ll spend much of my 2027 yelling at them to get their heads out of their asses and actually build a plan for Quebec that isn’t merely Referendum Bad.
Quebec Solidaire will exist. Their success will all be based on local candidates in local races and I have no insights. Mid-to-high single digits in seats.
But the story is how many Conservatives win. If the Liberals win 35, the CAQ win 5, and QS get 7 - all very rough estimates - that leaves 80 seats. 64 is majority government, so the Conservatives would in this scenario need to win 17 seats to stop a majority, and 24 to ensure that the pro-referendum parties don’t have enough for a majority. Narrowly I’d say they could get it, because I think the Conservative wave is going to continue, and that will mean beating their polling. They’re at 20% in both Leger and Pallas, and rising in both. If the trend continues through, you could see 22% easily, and that’s the kind of number that gets you to the mid-20s in seats.
If federalist voters are willing to be tactical - also known as if Liberals in the 450 realize that they can’t win - then the floodgates on the Conservative seat total open, and hitting 30 seats is on the table. But it’s also still true that there are so many unpredictable seats that the PQ could win a disproportionate number of them and end up with a comfortable majority. This is really all to play for.
But for some reason, I’m feeling optimistic. The PQ doesn’t feel like a party about to win majority government. They feel staid and boring in a way that’s not really conducive to beating their polling, and I think the Duhaime surge is exactly the kind of thing that blunts their chances of sweeping anti-referendum places on vote splits so egregious it should come with a parental advisory.
All in, Quebecers face a monumental choice on Monday. Incumbents often frame the choice as stability versus chaos, but here it’s chaos no matter what, just in different flavours. The instability of a referendum or the insanity of a hung Parliament where the PQ are in office, but not in power.
For both Canada and Quebec’s sakes, don’t let a referendum make us all worse off. The damage it’ll do to investment and opportunity is not worth it for a vanity project that will not succeed. I have faith Quebecers have enough sanity to not allow themselves to be taken to the edge of crisis with less than 30%.
I think it’ll be a PQ minority without a majority for a referendum. But I don’t know. And that’s why Monday represents a dividing line in our modern history - an opportunity to reject division and economic vandalism in the name of solving real problems Quebec actually faces. Please fucking take it.

PQ minority. Liberals will be in 2nd. Who knows how much the QS will prop up the PQs. But I suspect there will be another election in 6-8 months.
I suspect that a PQ win, majority or minority, is going to come as a surprise to much of ROC; there have been many other things to preoccupy us! And for those of us old enough to remember the '70s, '80s and '90s, I don't think that there will be nearly as much willingness now to let Quebec dramas get such a large share of national time and attention again. We've moved on.
During those years, the federal Liberals were pretty successful at selling themselves to ROC as the ones who could be the Quebec whisperers, and they were given a fair amount of latitude to manage that aspect of federalism. So, middle class parents in BC and Ontario could enroll their kids in French Immersion and vote Liberal federally, and most of the time didn't need to feel that anything more was needed. Consequently, a lot of space in a lot of brains could be given over to other concerns, as well as aspects of being Canadian that are more satisfying and actually fun.
On top of this, the ugly side of Quebec ethno-nationalism has become a lot harder to ignore in recent years. And those impressions have been reinforced by what we've absorbed from members of the Quebec Anglo diaspora in our workplaces and social circles.
So there will be a lot smaller reservoir of patience in ROC for indulging self-absorption and whining on the part of Quebec. And don't get me started on Alberta!