Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Maureen Cam's avatar

This is the best column I have ever read that you've written Evan, It is absolutely to the point and needs to be said. Canadian media needs to step up and get the stories straight, no more "stenography".

Expand full comment
Wes's avatar

I came here after reading some heated exchanges on Twitter expecting to leave an angry comment but this piece had some fair points for me to dig into deeper on references, so thank you for that and for encouraging me to consider the fear Jewish Canadians must be feeling here at home with recent events.

That said, I am having a hard time squaring the idea that criticism of the Israeli government and its policies (which I equate with Zionism and which Jama seems to) is anti-semitism. That seems to be one of the points you're making here and it's one I'm seeing commonly thrown around. I can't say what's in Jama's heart, and I admit that there are some acts of omission combined with her presence alongside some unsavoury statements by others at rallies that give one some doubt on that front - but the statements I've seen her make, mainly the written one that got her censured and more recently about establishment political bias thanks to lobby groups like CIJA, don't seem particularly problematic to me (CIJA has spent over $800k on ~70 active MPs in trips to Israel so they're clearly buying access). Advocating for a ceasefire has to include advocating for an end to oppression and systems of apartheid otherwise nothing will change, and that naturally involves critiques of Zionism and questioning why our politicians are consistently making statements at odds with their constituents.

Sidenote: Jama has a libel case against Ford which I think is separate from the threatened one against the censure that you reference from the article. The libel case seems to have a reasonable chance given how unhinged the Premier's statement was. I don't know whether the Spectator or Jama is conflating the two or if they're one and the same.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts